Side By Side Comparison

From MiOS
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 10: Line 10:
 
| align="center" | '''''Price'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Price'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Retail Price || $299 || $179 || Not sold separately || The Schlage Bridge appears to be available only as part of a bundled kit.  The Schlage locks are available without the Schlage Bridge for $100 less.
+
|| Retail Price || $299 || $179 || Not sold separately || The Schlage Bridge is available only as part of a bundled kit.  The Schlage locks are available without the Schlage Bridge for $100 less.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Monthly charge || Optional || $9.99 || $12.99 || Schlage requires a monthly subscription or else they block remote access to the lock.  Hawking requires a monthly subscription of $9.99 for cell phone access.  Vera's provides secure remote access, cell phone control, and email notifications for free.  SMS texting and video archiving are $29/year.
+
|| Monthly charge || Optional || $9.99 || $12.99 || Schlage requires a monthly subscription or else you cannot use the LiNK or control Z-Wave devices.  You can still manually operate the door without the subscription.  Hawking requires a monthly subscription of $9.99 for cell phone access.  Vera's provides secure remote access, cell phone control, and email notifications for free.  SMS texting and video archiving are $29/year.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Not dependent on manufacturer || [[Image:check.png]] || partial || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning if the manufacturer stopped supporting the product, would it still function.  With Vera, only the optional hosted online services depend on Mi Casa Verde, all local functions are independent.  In Hawking's case, cell phone access would stop but other functions would continue.  In Schlage's case, the product will not function at all if you don't pay the monthly bill or if Schlage discontinues support for the product.However the Lock itself will still function as a keypad lock. The remote capabilities will be disabled.  
+
|| Not dependent on manufacturer || [[Image:check.png]] || partial || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning if the manufacturer stopped supporting the product, would it still function.  With Vera, only the optional hosted online services depend on Mi Casa Verde, all local functions are independent, and Vera will run without an internet connection.  In Hawking's case, cell phone access would stop but other functions would continue.  In Schlage's case, the product will not function at all if you don't pay the monthly bill or if Schlage discontinues support for the product. However the Lock itself will still function as a keypad lock. The remote capabilities will be disabled.  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''Z-Wave Device Compatibility'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Z-Wave Device Compatibility'''''
Line 22: Line 22:
 
|| Light Switches/Appliance Modules || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]]  || [[Image:check.png]]  ||  
 
|| Light Switches/Appliance Modules || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]]  || [[Image:check.png]]  ||  
 
|-
 
|-
|| Thermostats || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || Schlage has said their LiNK now controls thermostats.  However we have heard reports that it only controls Trane thermostats (Schlage's sister company).  We are uncertain if it controls the other thermostats, like Wayne Dalton.
+
|| Thermostats || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] ||  
 
|-
 
|-
|| Door/Window/Motion Sensor || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Door/Window/Motion Sensor || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning Z-Wave door, window and motion sensors can trigger scenes, fire events, and you can be notified on your mobile phone
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Combo-sensors || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] || Such as the 3-in-1 light, temperature, motion sensor
 
|| Combo-sensors || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] || Such as the 3-in-1 light, temperature, motion sensor
Line 38: Line 38:
 
| align="center" | '''''Insteon/X10 Device Compatibility'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Insteon/X10 Device Compatibility'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support for Insteon/X10 || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Insteon/X10 || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''A/V Device Compatibility'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''A/V Device Compatibility'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support for Infrared control || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Infrared control || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Control TV's, stereo's, etc., with infrared emitters
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support for RS232 control || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| RS232 control || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || For those models of A/V devices that have serial control ports provides direct control without infrared
 
|-
 
|-
|| Universal remote control || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Universal remote control || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Use your mobile phone as a universal remote control
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''Alarm System Compatibility'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Alarm System Compatibility'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support for RS232 alarm panels || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| RS232 alarm panels || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Sensors from your traditional home alarm system can trigger scenes, notifications, etc., and you can remotely manage your home alarm
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support for USB alarm panels || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| USB alarm panels || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Same
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support for ethernet alarm panels || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Ethernet alarm panels || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Same
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''IP Devices Compatibility'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''IP Devices Compatibility'''''
Line 60: Line 60:
 
|| Generic IP Cameras || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Vera works with any IP camera that can return a JPEG file, such as Panasonic and most IP cameras.
 
|| Generic IP Cameras || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Vera works with any IP camera that can return a JPEG file, such as Panasonic and most IP cameras.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Proprietary IP Cameras || n/a || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] ||  
+
|| Proprietary IP Cameras || n/a || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || Schlage offers their own brand of IP cameras that are not accessible with a normal web browser and cannot be used without the LiNK subscription.  Hawking also has a proprietary camera.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Pan/Tilt/Zoom || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Pan/Tilt/Zoom || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Ability to move camera and adjust it remotely
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''Z-Wave features'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Z-Wave features'''''
Line 86: Line 86:
 
|| PIN codes trigger events || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || For example, you give the pool cleaner a PIN code and are notified by SMS when he unlocks the door with his PIN code
 
|| PIN codes trigger events || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || For example, you give the pool cleaner a PIN code and are notified by SMS when he unlocks the door with his PIN code
 
|-
 
|-
|| Support all door locks || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Vera will also support the Black & Decker door locks when they are on the market. Schlage has indicated their bridge will only work with Schlage locks
+
|| Support all door locks || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Vera will also support the Black & Decker door locks when they are on the market.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''Automation'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Automation'''''
Line 95: Line 95:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Events || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || For example, turn on a light when a motion sensor is tripped.
 
|| Events || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || For example, turn on a light when a motion sensor is tripped.
 +
|-
 +
|| Relative to sunset/sunrise || [[Image:check.png]] ||  ||  || Meaning trigger a scene 1 hour before the sun rises, etc.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" | '''''Remote access'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Remote access'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Direct access over IP || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning you can directly control the device over the internet or local network
+
|| Direct access over IP || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning you can directly control the device over the internet or local network without going through a remote server
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Works when your internet is down || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning you can still control and configure the system from within the home if your internet connection is down
 
|| Works when your internet is down || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning you can still control and configure the system from within the home if your internet connection is down
 
|-
 
|-
|| Secure remote access through a gateway || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || Both Vera and Schlage use a secure server similar to that for online banking.  Vera offers this with the [[Find_Vera_Service]] service
+
|| Secure remote access through a gateway || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || Both Vera and Schlage use a secure server similar to that for online banking.  Vera offers this for free.  Schlage offers it for a $13/month subscription.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| align="center" |  '''''Energy monitoring'''''
 
| align="center" |  '''''Energy monitoring'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Tracks energy usage || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Tracks actual energy usage || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning it supports the Z-Wave classes for reporting current Watts, accumulated KwH, etc.
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Reports historical energy usage || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Vera shows past energy usage by room, type of device, etc.
 
|| Reports historical energy usage || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Vera shows past energy usage by room, type of device, etc.
Line 120: Line 122:
 
| align="center" | '''''Remote Control'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Remote Control'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Custom remotes with your own skins/buttons || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Custom remotes with your own skins/buttons || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] || For example, put an iPod touch on the wall which your own wallpaper and pictures and icons that trigger scenes or control devices.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Web interface on local home network || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Web interface on local home network || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]]  || [[Image:x.png]] || Direct access by http://[your bridge's IP address]
 
|-
 
|-
|| Web interface for secure remote access over the internet || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] ||  
+
|| Web interface for secure remote access over the internet || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || Access going through a remote server via https
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Cell phone access || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] ||  
 
|| Cell phone access || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:check.png]] ||  
 
|-
 
|-
|| Wi-fi access (iPod Touch, PDA's, etc.) || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Wi-fi access (iPod Touch, PDA's, etc.) || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning PDA's, iPhone's, and other wi-fi enabled devices can directly control the bridge using your home network
 
|-
 
|-
|| Handheld remotes || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || You can add handheld remotes to any Z-Wave network, including Schlage and Hawking, but neither Schlage nor Hawking allow you to control their gateway with the remote
+
|| Handheld remotes || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning a button on a handheld remote, such as a the popular Intermatic Z-Wave remotes, can trigger a scene in the bridge, such as making the bridge lock a door or adjust the thermostat.
 
|-
 
|-
 
|| Scene controllers || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Same as handheld remotes above
 
|| Scene controllers || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Same as handheld remotes above
Line 144: Line 146:
 
| align="center" | '''''Open-ness / geek-friendly'''''
 
| align="center" | '''''Open-ness / geek-friendly'''''
 
|-
 
|-
|| Direct login allowed || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Direct login allowed || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || Meaning you can login to the system with telnet/ssh to inspect the software, verify the strength of the encryption, etc.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Allows custom scripts || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] ||  
+
|| Allows custom scripts || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || You can write your own scripts to automate tasks, which scripts run in the bridge.
 
|-
 
|-
|| Published API's for custom add-ons and UI's || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || See: [[Data_Provider_Catalog_Plugin]] [[ZWave_Status]] [[UI_Notes]]
+
|| Published API's for custom add-ons and UI's || [[Image:check.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || [[Image:x.png]] || See: [[Luup_Intro]]
 
|}
 
|}

Revision as of 21:47, 27 July 2009

This is meant to be an informative, objective comparison of Vera and the other Z-Wave gateways, not a 1-sided sales pitch. If other Z-Wave gateways have features we have not listed, you can add those features. You can also add other gateways that are not on the list, and correct any mistakes and add notes. This document is a wiki, editable by the public.

Note that this document, being a wiki, contains data provided by the public and our customers as well as those of our competitors. The list of features supported by the Schlage and Hawking products comes from customers who use those products and Mi Casa Verde has not independently verified all the features of our competitors products. If there are any inaccuracies, anybody is able to correct them.

NOTE: To ensure the comparison to the Schlage LiNK is as accurate as possible, we have purchased our own LiNK and are working with Schlage to verify the current feature set of the LiNK. See the discussion page for the comments and observations so far.

Vera Hawking HRPG1 Schlage LiNK Bridge Notes
Price
Retail Price $299 $179 Not sold separately The Schlage Bridge is available only as part of a bundled kit. The Schlage locks are available without the Schlage Bridge for $100 less.
Monthly charge Optional $9.99 $12.99 Schlage requires a monthly subscription or else you cannot use the LiNK or control Z-Wave devices. You can still manually operate the door without the subscription. Hawking requires a monthly subscription of $9.99 for cell phone access. Vera's provides secure remote access, cell phone control, and email notifications for free. SMS texting and video archiving are $29/year.
Not dependent on manufacturer Check.png partial X.png Meaning if the manufacturer stopped supporting the product, would it still function. With Vera, only the optional hosted online services depend on Mi Casa Verde, all local functions are independent, and Vera will run without an internet connection. In Hawking's case, cell phone access would stop but other functions would continue. In Schlage's case, the product will not function at all if you don't pay the monthly bill or if Schlage discontinues support for the product. However the Lock itself will still function as a keypad lock. The remote capabilities will be disabled.
Z-Wave Device Compatibility
Guaranteed compatible with all Z-Wave devices Check.png X.png X.png Vera is free if it doesn't work with all your Z-Wave devices as explained here. Note: Z-Wave devices must be certified by Zensys/the Z-Wave alliance to be called Z-Wave and to qualify.
Light Switches/Appliance Modules Check.png Check.png Check.png
Thermostats Check.png Check.png Check.png
Door/Window/Motion Sensor Check.png Check.png X.png Meaning Z-Wave door, window and motion sensors can trigger scenes, fire events, and you can be notified on your mobile phone
Combo-sensors Check.png X.png X.png Such as the 3-in-1 light, temperature, motion sensor
Handheld remotes Check.png X.png X.png Meaning handheld remotes can activate scenes in the gateway and be programed within the gateway
Door locks Check.png X.png Check.png
Scene controllers Check.png X.png X.png Same as handheld remotes
Supports European Z-Wave Check.png X.png X.png You must order the Euro version of Vera to support European Z-Wave
Insteon/X10 Device Compatibility
Insteon/X10 Check.png X.png X.png
A/V Device Compatibility
Infrared control Check.png X.png X.png Control TV's, stereo's, etc., with infrared emitters
RS232 control Check.png X.png X.png For those models of A/V devices that have serial control ports provides direct control without infrared
Universal remote control Check.png X.png X.png Use your mobile phone as a universal remote control
Alarm System Compatibility
RS232 alarm panels Check.png X.png X.png Sensors from your traditional home alarm system can trigger scenes, notifications, etc., and you can remotely manage your home alarm
USB alarm panels Check.png X.png X.png Same
Ethernet alarm panels Check.png X.png X.png Same
IP Devices Compatibility
Generic IP Cameras Check.png X.png X.png Vera works with any IP camera that can return a JPEG file, such as Panasonic and most IP cameras.
Proprietary IP Cameras n/a Check.png Check.png Schlage offers their own brand of IP cameras that are not accessible with a normal web browser and cannot be used without the LiNK subscription. Hawking also has a proprietary camera.
Pan/Tilt/Zoom Check.png X.png X.png Ability to move camera and adjust it remotely
Z-Wave features
Works as a primary controller Check.png Check.png Check.png
Works as a secondary controller Check.png Check.png X.png
Can be added to an existing Z-Wave network Check.png Check.png X.png
Supports controller shift Check.png Check.png X.png
Door lock specific
Secure remote locking/unlocking of doors Check.png X.png Check.png
Secure remote setting of user codes Check.png X.png Check.png
Control of doors from handheld remotes and scene controllers Check.png X.png X.png Meaning a button on a Z-Wave handheld remote or scene controller can be programmed, for example, to turn off the lights and lock the doors. Schlage only allows controller through the Schlage interface.
Door locks trigger events Check.png X.png X.png For example, when you unlock the door the porch light comes on automatically.
PIN codes trigger events Check.png X.png Check.png For example, you give the pool cleaner a PIN code and are notified by SMS when he unlocks the door with his PIN code
Support all door locks Check.png X.png X.png Vera will also support the Black & Decker door locks when they are on the market.
Automation
Scenes Check.png Check.png Check.png
Timers Check.png Check.png Check.png
Events Check.png Check.png Check.png For example, turn on a light when a motion sensor is tripped.
Relative to sunset/sunrise Check.png Meaning trigger a scene 1 hour before the sun rises, etc.
Remote access
Direct access over IP Check.png X.png X.png Meaning you can directly control the device over the internet or local network without going through a remote server
Works when your internet is down Check.png X.png X.png Meaning you can still control and configure the system from within the home if your internet connection is down
Secure remote access through a gateway Check.png Check.png Check.png Both Vera and Schlage use a secure server similar to that for online banking. Vera offers this for free. Schlage offers it for a $13/month subscription.
Energy monitoring
Tracks actual energy usage Check.png X.png X.png Meaning it supports the Z-Wave classes for reporting current Watts, accumulated KwH, etc.
Reports historical energy usage Check.png X.png X.png Vera shows past energy usage by room, type of device, etc.
Responds to energy alerts Check.png X.png X.png Vera allows automatic energy reduction when the utility company reports the power grid is overloaded. See Energy
Networking
Built-in router/gateway Check.png X.png X.png Hawking and Schlage require you to purchase these separately
Built-in wi-fi Check.png X.png X.png Hawking and Schlage require you to purchase these separately
Remote Control
Custom remotes with your own skins/buttons Check.png X.png X.png For example, put an iPod touch on the wall which your own wallpaper and pictures and icons that trigger scenes or control devices.
Web interface on local home network Check.png X.png X.png Direct access by http://[your bridge's IP address]
Web interface for secure remote access over the internet Check.png Check.png Check.png Access going through a remote server via https
Cell phone access Check.png Check.png Check.png
Wi-fi access (iPod Touch, PDA's, etc.) Check.png X.png X.png Meaning PDA's, iPhone's, and other wi-fi enabled devices can directly control the bridge using your home network
Handheld remotes Check.png X.png X.png Meaning a button on a handheld remote, such as a the popular Intermatic Z-Wave remotes, can trigger a scene in the bridge, such as making the bridge lock a door or adjust the thermostat.
Scene controllers Check.png X.png X.png Same as handheld remotes above
Online services
Archive of surveillance camera images Check.png X.png X.png All these online services are part of the Find_Vera_Service service
Archive of energy usage Check.png X.png X.png
Archive of events Check.png X.png X.png
Open-ness / geek-friendly
Direct login allowed Check.png X.png X.png Meaning you can login to the system with telnet/ssh to inspect the software, verify the strength of the encryption, etc.
Allows custom scripts Check.png X.png X.png You can write your own scripts to automate tasks, which scripts run in the bridge.
Published API's for custom add-ons and UI's Check.png X.png X.png See: Luup_Intro
Personal tools